it almost took me like 2.5 year to get it (nah i'm just kiddin i simply didn't open this game since like doc.2020 after i tried two or three times and failed, got tired and confused about it)


now as i understood, the point of this achievement is not only about all the things ( great riches, appetite suppressants, raw fish, lute, chisel and mallet, poison, love poison, to do list ) you give to the beggar, its actually more about you have nothing left after the donation


yes i think the whole idea was let the character say the magic word and the problem would be solved, which means you shouldn't have anything besides those 8 on you when you stepped into the church. considering i think things can‘t be tossed in this game, just promise me you won't take the uselessness!!!
(i used to ask the blind painter to draw some extra painting for me before i go to the poet, i think that's the reason why i couldn't unlock it, because the character still has something left )

(in fact, i guess even just donate some of those things on the list, make sure you don't have any un-donateable thing and let the character say that's all i've got would work as well, but i haven't tried yet. just sayin.)

does that make any sense? i think so. hope this would be helpful. enjoy! ;)

说真的，这玩意自从我三周目都没达成之后就气得再也不想打开这游戏了，前两天小黑盒更新个人主页我看着16/17的成就难受，才下回来重新做了一下。没在任何地方看到有人写这个成就的具体内容，我就多叭叭几句


（图源b站@谜之声，随手截的，侵删）

这次是直接奔着这个成就去的，没有在游戏里闲逛，拿齐所有任务必须品就走，给全了之后（懒得再打字了，看图应该能数明白，总共八个）立刻就跳了，角色说了一句thats all ive got，虽然我记不清一年多前玩的时候的具体内容了，但是直觉告诉我这句话是达成成就的关键（。）


就是“这是我的全部/我身上没别的了”，肯定是物品栏空了才会说。所以我自己猜之前跳不出成就是因为我身上还带着没法给乞丐的一两张画家给我画的无关剧情的画（可能也有其他东西，但太久了我记不清了。就是想做成就的朋友一定记住不要拿任何那八个以外的东西，不然一个档又废了。庆幸这游戏流程不长吧）

而且给我感觉即使不给全这八件，比如拿了四，五个，全都给他，只要确保身上是空的也能跳成就？这是我蒙的，懒得试了，有朋友试成没试成都可以吱个声

啰嗦完了